Alternative Advance Fallacy

(a.k.a. Lose-Lose Situation)

A choice offered between two things that are the same thing


Teacher: Three theories of evolution exist. We’ve studied Neo-Darwinism, punctuated equilibrium, and theistic evolution. Which one do you believe?

Student: I don’t believe any of these. God revealed to me that He’s the one who created the heavens and the earth and everything in them in six days.

The teacher offered more than one choice, but the choices the teacher offered were the same choice. Every choice was a choice of evolutionism.